Question for the high(er) millage folks

mrbdm99 · #1 02-01-2010, 06:15 PM

OK, so I have a 2001 x5 3.0 with approx 112k miles. I really have no idea how many of those are highway miles before we got it (at 8x,xxx miles two years ago), but 90% of all the new miles we have put on it are highway miles.

I really should have done a bit more research when I got it, but, like most of you I am sure, I couldn't help but get it as soon as I drove it. It just felt right. If I would have looked around a bit, I would have probably realized the dealer was charging a good bit too much, but that is neither here nor there.

Outside of oil changes, I have had to get the steering rack replaced as it started to bind and that *knock on wood* is the biggest drama I have come across. I recently took it to my mechanic to have him do a once over with this last oil change and he found about 1700 dollars worth of stuff to do, nothing pressing, but stuff he believes will need replacing sooner, rather than later. Not a huge deal, but here in lies my delima... Stay with me a bit because, as you can see, I'm rather wordy, but I will do what I can to keep it short.

We drive to see family quite a bit, we always take two dogs, a baby (meaning carseat), and all related gear. For a weekend or a week, the amount of gear we tote is about the same. That is to say, it is a lot of stuff. We generally come back with more than we left with and that really taxes the amount of room in the x5. A quarter the time, I can't see out the back window due to everything in the back seat (can't put much in the very back due to the dogs). In about 5 months, we will have a second baby + related stuff to tote. We will be needing more room. My wife's solution is to put the dogs up in a "doggy hotel", but that is almost as pricey as getting work done on the x5, so they will continue to come with us. I don't see that changing. My second concern is that with that many miles, I am probably going to have bits and pieces (like right now) that come up that need to be replaced from here on out (an o2 sensor here, a faulty speaker there, etc). So, that leads me to the thoughts of replacing it for something with more room. Keeping cost in mind, 05 MDX's and 05 XC90's are priced about right and offer a good deal more space. 05 SRX's are priced even better with more people space, but about the same cargo space (all three with the 3rd rows folded flat for now). We even, gasp (though, I admit I love them because I am a truck guy too) drove a Tahoe with the new six speed auto and it was smooth, quite, and huge. Those are priced about 10k too much for me right now though, but, 10k isn't a huge sum in the overall scheme of things.

So, as you can see, I'm really torn on 1) do I keep the x5 or 2) do I move up to something bigger. I really love how the x5 drives and feels, but I am a bit scared of maintenance costs that are potentially lurking around the corner. Anyone around here with these higher millage cars have any insite into the problem? I really also don't want to keep putting money into a car that is worth (according to Carmax) slightly less than I owe... So yeah. Any thoughts would be appreciated!

X5Dawg · #2 02-01-2010, 06:31 PM

If you are questioning it, dump it for something larger and more reliable. I have spent quite a bit in repairs ($12K+), but I have justified it with (1) I still love driving it and (2) I own it, free and clear.

Good luck!!

Werewolf · #3 02-01-2010, 06:31 PM

Rational argument. Get an 04-06 Acura MDX or get an early MDX that has replaced the tranny already (fails usually at 100k) It's bigger, it drives well and they are very reliable and have a good trunk (dog crates, etc)

As an outlier, you could also look at a used Landcruiser or LX470. Old and high mileage models are good value bets except for gas mileage

Irrational argument - nothing you get will drive like an x5.

mrbdm99 · #4 02-01-2010, 10:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Werewolf

Rational argument. Get an 04-06 Acura MDX or get an early MDX that has replaced the tranny already (fails usually at 100k) It's bigger, it drives well and they are very reliable and have a good trunk (dog crates, etc)

As an outlier, you could also look at a used Landcruiser or LX470. Old and high mileage models are good value bets except for gas mileage

Irrational argument - nothing you get will drive like an x5.

Yeah, there is a LX470 here that is a little older than I would like, but the miles are half what I have. I just can't stand the thought to lose the mpg's. In the x5, I get around 21 on the hwy. The Tahoe w/ the 6 spd gets the same (on regular even). The MDX is even better. I just don't know.

The irrational is really pulling hard. Everytime I go for a drive, it pulls me back in. I'll have it paid off this year, but again, I just hate the thought of sinking money in it. The used market around here just really isn't that great, I'd need to take a drive to DFW or something similar.

Repoman · #5 02-01-2010, 08:46 PM

If future repair costs are a major concern, that would be enough for me to get rid of it immediately. With the amount of stuff I have repaired on mine with just over 60K miles, it would scare the heck out of me to own one of these with 6 digits on the ticker.

You can't go wrong with Japanese cars from a reliability standpoint. Everything i own that is Japanese has been extremely reliable even above 100K. Conversly, my X has been a reliability nightmare. I do agree that my X is more exciting to drive but not to the point where I would spend a significant amount of money to keep it on the road.

I will be trading up pretty soon too for another Lexus, not because of mileage concerns or more room but solely because I'm tired of working on it every other weekend.

wullaby · #6 02-01-2010, 10:42 PM

I got a Toyota Sienna to tote my family and the X5 for all the bitches to ride in!