Here's a picture of the rotor that shows the abnormal wear that lead my mechanic to think it could either be an uneven rotor or a sticking caliper.
DSC_0232 by
MikeandGabby, on Flickr
The wear is not present on the entire rotor, just a section (about 1/3).
DSC_0238 by
MikeandGabby, on Flickr