Since you have no model or model year info...had to look generically...and I don't think that cover you pictured comes in other colors (at least not using my 06 4.4 as an example)...it's the regular or same color as all trunk material.
And many e53 don't have covers over the spare...just the lift up cargo floor on mine.
See item #17 in the diagram at this link:
http://bmwfans.info/parts-catalog/E53/USA/X5_4.4i-N62/L-N/dec2005/browse/vehicle_trim/trim_panel_trunk_floor/