Bad news... neither the specs you list, nor any specs that make sense to non-speaker-engineer types, will tell you ANYTHING about how those speakers will sound.

There is no way to tell other than to listening, preferably in a car.

Second (a distant second) is asking people whose opinions you trust.

I personally am not a fan of either of the speakers you list. There are far better sounding speakers out there.

__________________
musicar northwest, portland oregon

musicarnw.com

The West Coast BMW audio experts