My original carrier lasted 120k then I bought a URO brand and it lasted 4 months but the warranty from the ebay company was 90 days. I then bought a Febi from Bavarian and it lasted 3 1/2 years , warranty 2 years and it broke at the weak spot on the shaft. Guess where I ordered the new one? FCP with the life time warranty! With the carrier problems and the window plastic clips failing I've had the door panel off a total of 12 times.

__________________
2004 X5 3.0 Auto 140k
2005 325xi Auto 108k
1988 325ix 5spd 279k