Stay away from the URO.

Personally, I used the VDO on my last replacement. This was for the left rear door. I replaced all bushings as well and it is the only door that sounds right when it is shut. Especially when the window is down.

If you plan on having the X for sometime, it may pay off in the end to use FCP for when the thing fails again? Just be sure to replace all of the bushings while you are there.

Good luck!

__________________
2004 X5 4.4 Build 01/04 Alpine White on Schwarz Dakota Leather, Anthracite Headliner
Xtrons Android HU, SPORT PKG, COLD WEATHER PKG(W/REAR HEATED SEATS AND HEATED STEERING WHEEL), CONVENIENCE PKG, FACTORY HITCH