Quote:
Originally Posted by X5chemist
If you were closer, I would let you test drive mine. City driving is good. The 4.11 gears get it moving smoothly. I agree, power really doesn't come on until 3000+ RPMs. At a swift acceleration, RPM shifts are high. The GM 5L40E speed works well.
|
I agree with the comments above; my M54 with the 5L40E is a good driver, whether in city traffic or on the highway.
Shifts are smooth and clean, and it accelerates onto freeways with no effort. Very nice for a 23 y.o., 212K mile, 5000 lb vehicle (mine has 300+lbs of tools in the trunk, always).
The 4.1 gear in the X is the same as on my '04 Chevy 2500HD, and I believe that the 5L40E shifts smoother at low rpms than the pickup's 4L80E heavy-duty auto (probably due to the difference in the X's having a 5-speed vs 4-speed in the pickup), but higher rpm shifts have the same "snap" in both vehicles.
I've been driving for almost 60 years now, and rate my aged 2001 X5 as one, if not
the, "best" of the cars/trucks I've driven or owned, for the overall feeling it imparts while behind the wheel. It feels solidly planted to the road (despite its' height), and still agile around curves and sweeping turns at higher speeds, only limited by the stock 17" all-season tires, but the AWD (first I've ever driven), and the rear-wheel camber pretty much makes up for the tires.
Only the '63 split-window Corvette (327-350hp, 4-speed manual) I had for a few days in '70, and my old '73 Volvo 142 (2.0L, 4-speed, suspension modified for track use...that I never actually got around to) imparted a similar "planted to the pavement" feeling, IIRC. Some other cars/trucks may have had more power, or agility (manueverability?), but for general usage, my X5 might just be my favorite. The previous owner renewed a great amount of suspension and drivetrain parts, while prepping the X for trading for my old '66 Chevelle drag car (unused for 13 years, so it needed to live again), and it feels really good to drive.
If I could ever get beyond all the niggling problems that I've had in the past three years with the X (recurrent lean codes, rear wiper, replacement of mechanical and auxiliary fans, no crank/battery problem most recently), I wouldn't hesitate to use my X more often, go on longer trips, and even give it to a daughter (which I don't have)...but not to my wife, who'd find a way to damage it (she has a history).
That's why I carry so many tools in the trunk (for on-the-spot fixes, if I can), but that's just me.