I’ve made some progress on my 4.4 rebuild and will update that work shortly. It’s still not done, but the bottom end is together, I finally got my heads back from the machine shop and installed the 4.6 cams, and put an eBay donor flex plate on so I could lock cylinder one at TDC in preparation for installation the heads and timing. Pics and write up soon.
Aside from the doors leaking, my right front outer CV axle boot has been throwing grease for at least two years (?). It was a new GKN piece I installed with the motor in 2002 and I really havent wanted to go through axle pulling brain damage. As such, I put some RV tape around it and kept shooting more grease into it via the small end of the boot with a grease gun for a while. No noise, but I’m sure the Red and Tacky in my grease gun isn’t doing the CV joint any good.
My plan was to re-boot it at some point, but recently I saw OE front right axles on clearance at FCP so I grabbed one. The GKN axles are OE, but have the soft rubber boots on them. I’ve been wondering if my X5 seems to shred boots more quickly due to the lift, or these aftermarket boots, so i decided to put new OE BMW boots on the new GKN axle and see how long they last. The BMW boots are much sturdier rubber and almost feel plastic-ish. Fortunately I had two new OE BMW boot kits (inner and outer) in my parts locker.
First up: pull the boots off the new axle and separate the two halves so as to get the new boots on.
New GKN axle comes with an axle nut and circlip on the diff side.

On inspection, the soft rubber boots on the new axle were already showing degradation in the small end folds, which I’ve always found to be where they end up throwing grease. This one was billed as “new” from FCP, but perhaps had been on the shelf for 20 years?

If you are doing both boots, it’s way easier to cut the boots off and pull the outer axle out of the inner cup, then remove the snap ring and pull the roller bearings off the inner side of the outer axle shaft half. This gives you access to both ends of the outer shaft so you can get the new boots on, but not have to pull the cv joint off the outer axle shaft which is held in by an axle circlip and loctite and can be a huge pain. The inner rollers are held on the splines with a snap ring so all you need is an appropriately sized snap ring tool (small).

Inner (roller) joint after cutting the boot off. The outer shaft just slides right out with the roller assembly on it.

Roller assembly after pull it out of the cup and held on the axle by the snap ring, which you can make out here. Note the different types of greases on the inner and outer joints. The BMW boot kits have the appropriate type included.

Outer CV style joint. Very difficult to get this assembly off of the axle shaft.
Snap ring comes off, roller assembly slides off, clean it all up, outer boot and clamps slide on, pack the cv full of grease, crimp the clamps.
You can see the whole thing here as I slide the pieces on to the outer axle shaft, under the strict supervision of my helper.

I’m not a big fan of the clamps, but I’m sure it’s a technique issue with me. I’ve got two separate tools to crimp them and found one works better on the smaller clamps, while the other works best on the larger ones.

The OE BMW branded inner boot has an “adaptor” piece which allows a larger boot to fit the right front inner joint. The GKN boot had a smaller end and fit the cup without this adapter. You can see it below:

After the roller is reinstalled with a new snap ring (included in the BMW kit) the boot and clamps slide on the axle, then pack it all with the included grease, slide the adaptor in and fit the into the boot, then the outer axle rollers slides into the inner cup, while finessing the adaptor over the cup (it sort of snaps into place affirmatively). Crank the clamps down and that’s it. Time will tell if it last, or if I got those sill clamps tight enough.

You can see the adaptor filling the space between the cup and the larger cv boot end. Odd, but maybe they use this same boot elsewhere on a larger joint, different car…?
I need to find some time to get the car on the lift and swap this axle in. I’ll tear the old one down and see how it looks after 2+ years of throwing grease. If it’s still good I’ll throw new boots on it and have a spare.