Just a suggestion, but you might want to order up some matching spray paint and just repaint the piece. You can buy a can of custom mixed paint in the factory color from a local auto paint store, or buy online. All you need is your paint code. I believe most replacement body parts come unfinished and will need to be painted anyways.

__________________
'06 X5 4.8is, TiAg/black, cold weather pkg., comfort seats
'07 750Li, TiAg/black, sport pkg.
'05 Ford F350 silver met./slate gray, Lariat, 6.0 PSD, CC, DRW, FX4