My 528i had those. It took lots o' elbow grease to remove them. I used 3M paint thinner on the fender liners. The good news was that the fresh coat of wax I had just applied made the paint very easy to remove with some spray detailer and several soft cotton towels.

__________________
DRIVER8

2017 Range Rover Sport Dynamic SC V8
2019 Jeep Wrangler Rubicon
2019 Ford F150 Limited

Allegheny Chapter BMW CCA
Mountain State Chapter BMW CCA