I never put much faith in Consumers Reports (or any of the other rating mags) because they miss the point on many of the things that really matter. They would give a Honda a higher rating than a BMW, but we all know which provides the best driving experience and which of the two you would prefer to drive. If you want the best, look at what the professionals use. Probably 90% are using Viking or Wolf. If you want something that's second tier, but better than most, look at something like Thermador, Dacor, etc.