depends on what you want out of your phone. i need to consolidate all my devices so i went with the treo

the treo is still one of the best out there. we have them ALL at my company and have to figure out how to hook them all up to corp email/services...

the Q sucks. 10 out of 10 people tried it returned it. its that simple.

treo gives you the most flexibility. i use mine to provide wireless internet for my laptop when i'm on the road. tons of programs that do anything you want it to do... plus the regular office tools work as expected. downside is the OS is buggy and locks itself causing a reboot about once every 2 weeks for me. i have the treo650 palm, and want to move to dr kewl's treo700p. not the winblows version...