From this list, I'd say Keyshawn Johnson is not even a middle-tier receiver. He has never lived up to the type. Add anyone who plays for the Raiders and Dolphins. Dante Culpepper, Chris Chambers, Randy Moss, Jerry Porter, and Lamont Jordan have suddenly become liabilities (especially for us FFL owners).

Eli Manning may not have all of the physical assets of his brother, but he's improved in each of his 3 seasons and can certainly be included in the next tier of QB's that rank behind P. Manning and McNabb.

Put Vick on team that knows how to utilize his talents and he becomes a perennial all-pro. Try to imagine Vick with the Cowboys with Jones, TO, Glenn, and Parcells or with the Redskins with Moss, Porter, and Gibbs. Atlanta simply has not figured out how to use Vick.

Big Ben has already proven his ability to play big in big games and as a 3rd year quarterback, he's still developing. Unfortunately, he's gone through more injuries and issues in one season than most players go through in a career. He had an awful game last week and probably should have sat one more week after getting concussed the week prior and not getting in a full practice week.

Any of these 3 QB's would make a poor NFL team competitive.