The All Weather ones are much better, first because of the quality and secondly because of the design. The water runs down the little channels, away from the cuff on your pants and collects at the bottom and contains the melted snow. The other design is simply poor. BMW tried to give them to me when I got my X5, they lasted a week and I replaced them with the All Weather mats

__________________
2011 550xi Carbon Black/Oyster, M-Sport, Premium Package, Technology Package, Electronic Damper Control, Dynamic Drive, Comfort Access, Active Seats, Surround Cameras

2013 X5 5.0 Space Grey/Black, M-Sport, Premium Package, Technology Package, Comfort Access, Surround Cameras