Originally Posted by Denalio

Winter is arriving here in my part of Canada, late but it is here. I will be needing winter tires for my 2007 4.8i with sport package. I will be purchasing some 18" replicas and need a set of winter tires. My two choices would be Pirelli Scorpion Ice & Snow or Dunlop Grandtrek Wt M2, these are both non-runflats which should be alright for winter. I know this may be subjective, but which would you recommend as the better choice?