Here is a picture of both an original clip and a replacement one. You can see from the picture how the replacement clip's frame extends into the holder area leaving a little less room for your cup.


My BMW receipt says Clamping Parts Set, 51-16-9-111-091. For the quantity they have 1. It is unclear to me how many clips come in the set. They replaced 4 clips in my X. If the set came with 6 I wish they would have given me the other two.

If you go out to pelicanparts.com and enter this part number, the website returns a price of $18.90. It would seem reasonable that this price is for a set of 6 and not for each one!

__________________
[Sold] 2004 X5 4.4i - Sterling Gray - Truffle Brown, Sport, Preminum, Rear Climate, DSP, Sirius, PDC, 132's (19 inch wheel), Comfort Seats
Dynavin, JL Audio Stealthbox, Alpine PDX-5 Amp