I just read the CR test of Upscale SUVs, they but the X5 below almost every model except for the Land Rover LR3 and the Lincoln MRX. The top rated is the Toyota Highlander Hybrid, the Lexus RX and the MDX. I kind of understand that in that reliability is a big factor for them but placing the Volvo XC90 the Q7 and the Cadillac SRX above the X5 makes no sense.