I think you guys might be thinking of C&D. They just did an E92 335i vs. "all new" G37S. It was not a landslide for BMW. They focused more on the G37S being an improvement over the G35 and that it's cheaper than the BMW. About two months ago C&D compared the E90 328i vs. G35 and the E90 won hands down but again, they mentioned the price disparity in favor of the G35.

__________________