We just sold the +1's Boxster S a couple of months ago, as she wanted the new 3 convertible to carry all her golf clubs, buggy, etc. Guess what: there was more room in the Boxster's two boots than in the BMW with the roof down (We bought the BMW off the catalogue, it hadn't been released in Australia at the time.)

I really liked the Porsche, and am seriously considering getting one for myself now. The balance, comfort, style, performance and reliability of the S was great, and I've run the gamut of Lotus, HSV's, etc etc. IMHO, the Boxster S is what I want, even against a stock 911.

My 2 cents worth