They're giving you the rubber mats for free? All I got was the cheap carpeted mats.

Go for the 1st one. My thing about free stuff is get the most expensive one. If you don't like it, you can always sell it and get the cheaper one. Either way, you definitely need rubber mats to protect your carpet from the sand and salt water. I would probably get the 1st one myself.

__________________
2007 E70 3.0