Originally Posted by wilson

Thanks for the reply fast4d. Yes it is the valley pan gasket that is leaking.

The dealer will cover all parts including hoses under the warranty but I have to pay for the labor cost, $900.00.

It will takes 7.5 to 8 hrs. works, It's good I noticed now before the warranty expires.

I was just wondering, if this is a common problem with 4.4 x5, did anybody think that this might be a subject for a recall. my x5 is 2002 and has only 108,645 km on it.