lemans, as I posted back in the first response to your question,
they are, imo, all very good oil products for your X...and most
here, would concur.

The bmwcca guys, (I'm one, too, as are many of us here), are
not any more expert than any gang of car talking nuts.

If you want "Oil Threads", this board has them by the encyclopediac
quantity and length, ranging from really good posts to arm wrestle bs...

My orig. point and my point again, is that they are all very good oil brands
for a modern car driven on the streets in fairly normal conditions. This
isn't ProStock or even weekend club racing...

And, your orig post was to seek opins on those brands and weights and
I suspect you now want to argue why you want some other brand than
Mobil 1 0W-40; so go buy another brand. Save the bs arguments and data
and pages of "why"...

Use the Search Tab here first. If you really have a diff. viewpoint that we
all haven't already beaten to a pulp or a really different spin on "the best oil
to put in my X to drive around the fine province of Nova Scotia, Maritimes",
than keep on keeping on.
GL,mD