Originally Posted by Seattle53

Sorry but it sounds like you may have a stripped drain bolt/oil pan.

The right way to fix it is to drop the oil pan and either 1.) buy and replace with a new oil pan and drain plug or 2.) see if you can have the oil pan rethreaded and buy a new drain plug. Either way, the pan needs to be dropped.

Hopefully its not this but it sure sounds like it. Good luck!