Originally Posted by FSETH

It is a fast car, but come on. You have to admit that it seems like a step backward going from BMW to Caddy as far as the entire driving experience is concerned. I am a true BMW fanatic, but I am also a german car nut. I would gladly take an RS-4 over the Caddy anyday regardless of performance numbers.

It is a fast car though. No denying that and it is by far the best sedan offering from the US, but still not the complete car that the more refined German offerings are, IMO.