I also feel it was a tie though a tie for McCain is a win for Obama considering the topic. McCain seemed tired as well he should be with back and forth to Washington. Obama's cramming for the exam paid off and he came across better than he had in past interviews where he seemed long winded.

McCain was himself for the most part and Obama was coached and polished like the good student he is in real life.

Problem is he's still a student. He might actually one day make a good president but not now.