Thanks for the info Denalio. Dealer down here will do anything to avoid work, which is stupid if you ask me since BMW pays for their labor.

The BMW engineer looked at it and said it was a stone chip, I said how the hell is it a stone chip if the outside is still smooth? That much impact on the bottom of the lens will also chip the bumper, but that part is super smooth too.

I told the engineer about this tread, his comment was that "He doesn't look at anything on the internet". LOL

After I commented on his unwillingness to help a customer, he reluctantly agreed to look at the pictures you posted, but I doubt he actually looked at them. What a bunch of crock these guys are. It makes me not want to get another BMW.