I ordered the Titanium Liftgate handle about 2 months ago under the 1st part # that you ordered. As far as I know, that is the right one - as per X5 Accessories Catalog.

I don't know how much difference the color would be from your stock one though. It might be similar, but I'm not sure.........I doubt it would be the same color.

***THIS IS MY 100th POST!!!!!******

__________________
Sold - 2002 X5 3.0i - Steel Gray Metallic/Gray Interior
Mods: DINAN Stage 1 Engine Software; DINAN Stage 1 Transmission Software/OEM 87's!! /OEM Titanium Grill /OEM Chrome Exhaust Tips/OEM White Sidemarkers/OEM White Tail Lights/OEM White 3rd Brake Light/OEM Rubber Floor Mats/OEM Titanium Liftgate Handle/'06 Sport Steering Wheel

2005 Mercedes Benz ML350 Special Edition
2007 Mercedes Benz C230 Sport (for work)
1989 Ford Mustang GT (all original w/80k miles) my TOY!