mtX5- they are exactly the same, except the Bimmian's one is with the connector that plugs straight to the original socket.

sobi611- I had similar issue, except the new rubber seal was too THICK, I had to trim it a bit in order to fit. Which actually is good because it very nice and tight now ;-)

__________________

Here's the Photo Album of my (sold) X3; Album of my (newish) X5 is on the way!
(WARNING: read this before you buy anything from Umnitza)