The BMW regional engineer is going to hear it next, in these engines they have to replace the block and pistons, and that is a lot of money hence the reason they argue I think, I have seen articles that say I should not worry and articles that say I should worry, my 4.4 never had this noise when cold, the 4.6 is OK when warm. It does worry me, sounds like one cylinder only, but maybe two,
Geoff.