I'm venturing into New York from Boston to take my GF to see the Rockettes Friday night, and I'd like to make some dinner reservations in the Times Square area. I don't know New York at all, but I know there are some food buffs on here. Does anyone have recommendations? We eat everything, but really we're looking for some good atmosphere. Nothing TOO expensive either, we're not looking for $100 steak or anything!

Fire away!!!

Thank you!