My position would normally be that I would not care if the vehicle had been fix and repaired as I image this is not an uncommon occurrence. (I think most new car buyer just don’t know when there were incidents that require correction - either on the line or at the dealer).

So, as long as it was put back together right and warranted, no big deal.



However, in your case, I would insist that the vehicle be repaired with:

1. the correct window,
2. the available window with it’s antenna functional and warranted for function,
3. the promise that when the correct window becomes available, it will be installed,
4. a discount for the incorrect window – which may lead to questions at resale time.

Unfortunately option B above poses some further issues:

• If it is install functionally, and the correct window is replaced at a later time (because it gets smashed or replaced for any other reason), will the place that puts in the new glass know how to make the antenna functional?
• If the glass has to be replaced again in the future with a non-antenna version who will be responsible for making the vehicle work with the normal antenna?

As for the radiator and BMW refusing to warranty it, I am assuming that means that BMW will not pay for the repair cost? The dealer having to swallow this is no issue, but what will happen to the vehicle if in the future there is another problem with the radiator? Will you be SOL? Is BMW washing it’s hands of the radiator altogether or just for this specific repair.

I imagine they are just not interested in paying for the repairs, but I would check to be sure of (and get it in writing) who is responsible for what repairs in the future to the replaced parts.

__________________
2006 X5 Sport 4.4i