On the 2011 X5 35D, all the fender holes for the passenger side arch line up perfectly. On the driver side is there one hole at the top of the fender that doesn't line up. So it seems the 10's have both sides affected, the 11's just the driver side so maybe the 12's will get it right! I shaved down one of the used plastic rivets and siliconed it over the hole, we'll see how long that lasts.