So, to understand how you are explaining this: basically they are selling the '10 for $51,800 and offering $19K for the trade ? I believe it is true that current model years can't be a CPO + I think there is a mileage minimum of like 5K anyways. If that is the deal it doesn't sound too bad on the '10--now for the trade it's up to you if you want that extra few $ on trying to go private party or not.