Originally Posted by Jordo

Great reading man! I only took about 15 mins to look over this (at work when I saw your post) I plan on sitting down and really going over this, and taking notes too.

But I have a few quick questions.
1st) what is the call name to our X5 trannys? ZF 5HP24
2nd) if it's not the same name, are the componets the same? ours is a newer box
3rd) what was shown with the dude who was in Germany is that sold complete, so I could just install the new "brain" as he called it and just throw mine away? You can replace a Valve Body with out removing all the transmission.
One part of my tranny's Valve body was replaced,which one is carrying main pressure piston and the piston itself,since then I have no Lurch present at all..and it's been a year since that,also I had all the X's modules reflushed.Shuddering is still present,but as everyone is stating just when I am being light on gas,so usually I am not now

Thank you for your input! You really go my gears turning! lol.