12-11-2010, 02:14 AM
|
 |
Member
|
|
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Kirkland, WA to Alexandria, VA - Now in Marysville, WA
Posts: 4,001
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by JCL
I don't agree that it never hurts to change the transmission fluid and filter. In fact, changing transmission fluid can cause a failure in some cases. That is because the new fluid has lots of detergents, and cleans out the transmission. There is nowhere for all that cleaned out residue to go, if there is any. That said, if you want to change the fluid on the off chance that it gives you a little more time, go ahead. If your problem is a clogged filter, it would help, but it wouldn't address the issue of why your filter is clogged. If you do it, use factory spec fluid, and a new OE filter. You have to consider that your transmission is not healthy, though, so changing the fluid may make it worse or better. It shouldn't be considered a cure, rather a bandaid.
|
I can agree that sometimes chaning the fluid can be a way to speed up the means to an end. I remember when I was on Toyota Tacoma forums, and just like here, people had mixed reviews of changing fluid when their transmissions started giving them issues. Either way, if he calls/emails me, I'd be interested to take a look at it since my X doesn't exhibit any symptoms like this.
At this point it won't happen till after the new year, but I'm looking forward to doing a complete rebuild on a 5HP24 so I can see first hand what failed clutches, 1st/Reverse drums, etc look like when they break/fail.
__________________
650hp 10 X5///M - Stage 2, Vibrant 1794's , gutted cats, custom intake, AC Forged 22's 325hp 98 BMW 740iL - ///M5 6spd, www.bavengine.com w/ Performance Option, electric fan, CF intake tube w/ heatshield, Mag 14816 w/ notched bumper, Bilstein/H&R Stage II/Powerflex 600+hp 02 Harley F150 - MHP900 Stage 3 engine, KB2.3, 8# lower, 60# inj, Walbro FP's
135hp 01 TL1000R - M4 full exhaust, K&N, Yosh box, -1/+2 gears, 2CT's
|