Edmunds is really low. For the 2003 x5 I am looking at it has a private party value of $12,100 and the person is asking $16,000. I was not going to pay anything close o $16K but was not expecting Edmunds to be so low. The car is really nice but the remote door locks dont work and the drivers side power seat does not work based on that and the Edmunds price could not see offering more than $11000. Think they might be insulted.