Tough choice. IMO, it is a shame that the 128i is overshadowed and overlooked in the BMW line-up. The 135i may be faster, but the 128i's lighter weight, lower cost, and more reliable drivetrain make it a great car.

I haven't driven any of the new MINIs with DI, but I have always been fond of the R56, especially the JCW. However, whenever I go to seriously look at one, as fun as they are to drive, I am turned off by the price.

Having done ED with an M3, I would definitely do it, and do it soon, as its attraction to car enthusiasts will surely change in the coming years. With the EU cracking down hard on vehicle emissions, I would not be surprised to see Autobahns speed-limited everywhere. The future of the Nurburgring is in question as well. Plus, traffic enforcement is up across the EU, already insane fuel prices are sure to go higher, etc.