View Single Post
  #19  
Old 05-01-2011, 03:52 AM
HEISING HEISING is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Coquitlam B.C.
Posts: 104
HEISING is on a distinguished road
Our 2002 X5 has been nothing but problems since we bought it. Mostly all electrical problems. About 2 weeks ago, the alternator died. So I replaced it and all is well again....But for how long? This piece of crap that we spent way to much money on, is always having some issue. I have owned many vehicles, and by far this one has been the most trouble. I know that 2002 was the start of the ROHS solder initiative. Boy does it show! The alternator situation is extremely funny. There are no brushes in these water cooled alternators. No parts to wear except bearings. This should rarely fail. BAD DESIGN!
My Job is to take poorly designed electronics from industrial machines and re-design it so the chance of failure is greatly reduced. (Reducing down time) for the customer in the future. I run across this garbage all the time. I have owned Chevys in the past.....400,000+ Km on a brushed alternator. Now this isn't a great design, but come on. A little over 100,000 Km on the X5, and an alternator that has almost no parts that wear, is now faulty? According to this forum, this is the norm.
This is just one problem...How about the FSR? How about the DSC module? Steering angle sensor? TCM? The list goes on. The bottom line is BMW needs to hire a crew that understands how to design things properly. This kind of failure rate is 100% unexceptable. We will "never again" buy another BMW. Dealing with this kind of stuff at work is enough. I don't need to come home to it. I really hope somebody learns from this, so they don't have to go through the same hassles that we have had to deal with.
Yes BMW, the truth hurts!
Reply With Quote

Sponsored Links