Thanks. I looked around and couldn't find anything stamped on it. I couldn't find anything stamped on the other original doors either though. The paperwork says it is original BMW, but the fit just isn't right. I wonder if there was some other damage that was not repaired that is causing the fit to be off.

I'll call State Farm tomorrow and try to get an adjuster to come look at it. The first time I took it back, the body shop guy said not to call State Farm if there was a problem because they get in trouble. I guess I feel a little guilty about it, but at the same time, I'm also irritated that he tried to make me feel bad about it. They have had two opportunities to fix the problem. I can see the door whistle maybe taking a few tries, but the rattle in the door is unexcusable. So is returning the car to me with body shop sanding dust everywhere inside. I've had to clean the car twice now, and that alone makes me not want to go back to that particular shop. Am I being unreasonable?