Originally Posted by 4MoJoe

I went from 2004 E53 with 4.4i to the 2011 X35d. If I had the two in front of me today I'd probably go back to the E53 despite some the mechanical headaches. Mostly because it was a blast to drive. This fact hit me this week as I came across some old pics of my E53.

I like the power of the diesel, but as said before, it's heavier and doesn't feel nearly as nimble as my E53. I attribute part of that to the stupid 18" standard wheels. I had staggered 19's on my E53 and though it didn't have sport package it was much more fun in the twisties.

Don't get me wrong, my E70 is a NICE ride but def not on the sporty side.

In my decision process to buy new I drove my neighbors 2009 E70 with the 3.0si engine and I was happy with it, it led me towards the X35d but the 2009 had sport package and 19's and I think that's a good combo...just regretting not getting that sport package on my X35d...but had a hard time finding the price/options combo of an in stock car so compromised.