How is it foul play? It's the dealer....it's all a numbers game for them. I could be wrong on this, but if the dealer replaces the engine under the CPO warranty, doesnt BMW pay for it? Where as giving you 13k off a new purchase would come off the dealers bottom line, as they would be undoubtedly selling a vehicle at a loss...

I'm not sure what I would do in your case....but asking them to give you 13k off a new purchase because that's the cost for the engine replacement on a vehicle you didn't buy new (and is pushing 8 years) is somewhat unreasonable on your part, IMO of course.

__________________