It is cut and dry. There is not much to it. Warranty is a contract. Contract is expired/fulfilled, and they are still going to make good with a new motor at no cost to you!? What will they make you pay?... The $50 cpo deductible.... As the others said it is a no brainer. Asking to have the complete motor cost toward a new vehicle...talk about biting the hand that feeds you! If your vehicle never failed you would continue to drive it, and your life would go on. So complaining that the vehicle is old and it isn't worth a new motor is absurd... Look how many people drive 15 year old junk cars because they can't drive a BMW. Be lucky BMW takes care of people that obviously do not understand how contracts work, and stand by their product. Just remember they could have told you to pound sand!