Thank you for the reply. We did check into the lemon laws. If I recall, the law has a mileage qualifier. You see, we drive the X a lot more than the average person/family. The mileage, it seems.... disqualified it. I understand this.

We put on over 35K mileage per year on average. Really more, but it stays in the shop so much that figure is somewhat low.

We pick it up today with the new SCR cat and associated parts. The bad thing is the X diesel value is dropping like a rock, it appears. I have seen multiple copies of the 2011's selling for under 35K retail. If we want out, it will be an expensive endeavor. If we stay in it, it will surely hammer us in repairs in the future. I would hate someone else to have to deal with this vehicle.

I want to add, this vehicle has never been modified. It was a present to my wife. She wanted it left alone so it would be super reliable. LOL