You mean the black surrounding plate NOT the actual metal handle right?
cant help you with any experience.
but here are the part numbers for replacements, they are very cheap
12 Trim cover, door handle, front left SCHWARZ 1 51416969377 $7.10
12 Trim cover, door handle, front right SCHWARZ 1 51416969378 $7.10
For vehicles with
Light package
S563A=Yes
12 Trim cover, door handle, front left SCHWARZ 1 51416973735 $7.10
12 Trim cover, door handle, front right SCHWARZ 1 51416973736 $7.1
12 Cover, door opener, rear right SCHWARZ 1 51426969496 $7.10
For vehicles with
Light package
S563A=Yes
12 Cover, door opener, rear left SCHWARZ 1 51426973739 $7.10
12 Cover, door opener, rear right SCHWARZ 1 51426973740 $7.10