FNG: Taking the plunge - need advise

[DesertRat]

So my wife wants a new to her smaller SUV. We've drove many of the SUV's in the X5 class and have settled on the 4.4i.

Here is the question at hand assuming the condition of the vehicles are are all comparable, clean carfax, etc:

What of the three following cars is the best "value":

1) 2003 with 65k miles for $19k
2) 2006 with 50k miles for $29k
3) 2004 with 38k miles for $28k

Interested what the seasoned verterans have to say.

Thanks in advance,

-DR