Thoughts on Changing Transmission Fluid

[BMW_E53]

Decided to start a new thread on this topic. Have any of you guys ever changed the lifetime oil or ever thought about it?

[puddinboo]

it should be done as regular maintenance no fluid is life time I don`t care what anyone says.

[dkl]

This topic has been beaten to death. There are valid arguments on both sides...so use the "search" button above and draw your own decision/conclusion.

[Brandon002]

I got my X5 with over 100K miles on it. The trans would slam in to gear when taking off from a rolling stop.

Had the trans filter and fluid changed and the torque converter flushed. Trans shifts like butter now. There is no such thing as a lifetime fluid or filter. Unless of course you want the life of your car to be shortened.

[upallnight]

Originally Posted by Brandon002

I got my X5 with over 100K miles on it. The trans would slam in to gear when taking off from a rolling stop.

Had the trans filter and fluid changed and the torque converter flushed. Trans shifts like butter now. There is no such thing as a lifetime fluid or filter. Unless of course you want the life of your car to be shortened.

Did you do the fluid change yourself or did you take it to a dealer or indy. Which dealer or indy in Chi town?

[BMW_E53]

Hey Brandon002 I have the same year and model as you. Did you change the oil yourself? At what mileage did you change the oil?

[Brandon002]

I had a local german indy do mine. It was 419 including parts, labor and fluid. I figured it was worth it when parts and fluid alone were going to cost me 250 minimum.

[Whitecat]

Originally Posted by Brandon002

I had a local german indy do mine. It was 419 including parts, labor and fluid. I figured it was worth it when parts and fluid alone were going to cost me 250 minimum.

Just curious, how many liters they changed ?

[Brandon002]

Having them do it got me a torque converter flush too, which i wouldnt have been able to do at home.

[Brandon002]

146k miles.