| diogenes! |
07-10-2006 09:02 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by jaba
Do we have defensive measures for something that big? ala armageddon.
|
Deep Impact was the better movie of the two. :) Check out the movies section of the Bad Astronomy web site. Like Eric5273 pointed out, the "rock" in that video is nearly the size of Mercury. The good news is that our solar system is fairly mature and anything that size is either in a stable solar orbit or has been captured by one of the larger planets as a "moon". The bad news is(as Eric5273 also pointed out), getting hit by a smaller rock can be pretty bad.
NASA's NEAT is an ongoing project to identify and track all the asteroids that cross Earth orbit. That's why we were aware of the "close call" last week. I don't think that there are any real "defense" plans other than early identification of a threat. The only viable defense would be to attempt to alter the trajectory very early on when it would only take a slight change to make the rock miss us.
The movie plot of blowing up the asteroid(or comet as in Deep Impact) is a really bad plan - especially at the terminal end near Earth. This is well explained in the movies section of the Bad Astronomy site above. Basically, it can't be done and, if it could, then it wouldn't change the outcome. It's the impact of the total mass that matters. Also, it's better to have one large trackable rock than one thousand smaller ones.
|