S2000 or G35 Coupe?
 

Which would you get?

As a second car I'd pick the S2000. As an alternative to my e46 I'd pick the G35.

Between those 2...
 

I'd pick the G35. But I'd take the E90 330i over both of them. I would also seriously consider the new Lexus IS 350. JMO.

there are both great cars... depending on preference... in performance and aerodynamics... but i would pick the g35 coupe!

This is a tough one. Having owned a G35, they are nice cars, but I think the S2000 would be much more enjoyable. The seats in the G35 coupe look like La-Z-Boy recliners from the back. I haven't had a chance to check out the new IS350's, but I've seen a couple on the street and would definitely put that on the list.

I would go with the G35. It's a very energetic car.

I would get the G35.

Been there, done that. G35 all the way, really a great car.

Keep in mind i've already had a 350Z... I'm leaning towards the 06 S2000 w/ the 2.2 engine, just because Nissan/Infiniti had FLOODED the market w/ Z's and G's here in California.. you see them everywhere!!

The IS350 is of course in a higher price class than the S2000 and G35. However I would nonetheless recommend either an E90 or the IS.