Xoutpost.com

Xoutpost.com (https://xoutpost.com/forums.php)
-   X5 (E53) Forum (https://xoutpost.com/bmw-sav-forums/x5-e53-forum/)
-   -   Diagnostics (https://xoutpost.com/bmw-sav-forums/x5-e53-forum/113257-diagnostics.html)

Henn28 05-13-2021 09:35 AM

Diagnostics
 
After reading the various threads on which is the best diagnostics, etc. tool(s) to use, I think I’m going with PA Soft to do what I (think) I’ll need to do on my ‘02 4.4 e53. Obviously there are lots of options and adherents to one or another solution, or several, but I’ve got wife-diagnosed ADD and one brain cell so would like to keep it less clogged than it already is by going with one piece of gear to get me to a 90% if not better solution.

The last dedicated thread I read on this topic was from early 2020, so I wanted to just ping the hive-mind and see if anything new is on the market that I should look at.

I’ve owned my 02 since new, but have just re-acquired it from my kids, who are now off the daily payroll…mostly. I’ve got a pretty complete refresh planned that I’m sure will entail lots of screw ups and a need for code and fault reading, system level disgnostics and manipulation, and perhaps even some more complex coding in the future for engine displacement projects I envision once the college bills stop coming in.

My project is off to an inauspicious start after I shut the trunk with the negative terminal pulled when it stated raining. This isn’t the first time either that I’ll get to crawl to the “way back” and pull the trunk floor with me on it so I can reconnect the terminal. I’m waiting for my 4.8 cluster and re-programmed DME to arrive, so I’ve got time to think about the error of my ways.

Thanks in advance for any input.

RocketyMan 05-13-2021 11:18 AM

+1 on the BMW scanner 1.4.0 from PA soft. I've used this one and have it. I think it's great! Coding is made very simple, IMO. Also, if you do need to reprogram your cluster or change the vin (like I did) it is done very easily!

Bdc101 05-13-2021 12:17 PM

PA soft is great once it's working. I did not find it easy to get working though. It is great for coding too, but if you just need it for diagnostics, spend the $150 on a Foxwell and move on with your life. I went through many hours trying to figure out how to get the USB drivers to work, then later found that my cheap chinese OBD/USB connector from ebay had inexplicably stopped working, so I paid another $30 for an authentic one from the UK. And then found that every time I booted it up, I had to reinstall the USB drivers, because Windows update would blow them away periodically. It was a hassle at every turn. If you buy an authentic adapter and have an older laptop, by all means go for it.

crystalworks 05-13-2021 12:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Henn28 (Post 1203854)
My project is off to an inauspicious start after I shut the trunk with the negative terminal pulled when it stated raining. This isn’t the first time either that I’ll get to crawl to the “way back” and pull the trunk floor with me on it so I can reconnect the terminal. I’m waiting for my 4.8 cluster and re-programmed DME to arrive, so I’ve got time to think about the error of my ways.

There is an "emergency" mechanical release on the hatch under a trim piece. Or, I think I'd hook up a booster pack under the hood to give the truck power.

Never used pa soft so can't help there. Inpa, foxwell 520, and Carly user. All have their uses.

bcredliner 05-13-2021 12:31 PM

I have had no reason to do any coding. Have had several scanners. I am using the Foxwell scanner. Very intuitive.

RocketyMan 05-13-2021 01:25 PM

Looks like the "foxwell" crew rolled in... -_-

Setting up the driver for the BMW Scanner 1.4.0 is NOT that bad for anyone computer literate.

bcredliner 05-13-2021 01:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RocketyMan (Post 1203875)
Looks like the "foxwell" crew rolled in... -_-

Setting up the driver for the BMW Scanner 1.4.0 is NOT that bad for anyone computer literate.

Computer literacy has nothing to do, I dare to say, with the choice of anyone that prefers the Foxwell scanner.

Bdc101 05-13-2021 02:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RocketyMan (Post 1203875)
Looks like the "foxwell" crew rolled in... -_-

Setting up the driver for the BMW Scanner 1.4.0 is NOT that bad for anyone computer literate.


I'm a control systems engineer and programmer, I deal with computers all day every day and I would say I am as computer literate as you can get without being an actual IT/CS professional.

I would guess it took me 8-10 hours of work to get it working, including finding help on two forums. I got it working, yes, but it was a huge hassle, and is the sort of thing that may differ greatly in effort and trouble based on what hardware you are using. If you have an old XP laptop it probably won't be "that bad." I read the same sort of suggestion online ("not that bad") and ended up wasting several evenings and weekend afternoons.

I also have to suggest buying the authentic USB adapter and not the cheap chinese crap on eBay. That was part of my problem, it just stopped working out of the blue after the first time I got it working.

RocketyMan 05-13-2021 02:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bdc101 (Post 1203878)
I'm a control systems engineer and programmer, I deal with computers all day every day and I would say I am as computer literate as you can get without being an actual IT/CS professional.

I would guess it took me 8-10 hours of work to get it working, including finding help on two forums. I got it working, yes, but it was a huge hassle, and is the sort of thing that may differ greatly in effort and trouble based on what hardware you are using. If you have an old XP laptop it probably won't be "that bad." I read the same sort of suggestion online ("not that bad") and ended up wasting several evenings and weekend afternoons.

I also have to suggest buying the authentic USB adapter and not the cheap chinese crap on eBay. That was part of my problem, it just stopped working out of the blue after the first time I got it working.

Oh that's nice.

Well I work for a big corp...and when I call into my IT dept for assistance, I end up getting no help from them either...and their turn around times of 8-10hrs sounds about right--that's also usually after substantial escalations on the support ticket. I end up doing my own research and resolving the issue with my local admin rights. Last example was with my company's VPN. Anyway...

But for anyone lurking on this forum and post, I used all my SW, such as BMW Scanner 1.4.0, on Win10 platform. It isn't impossible nor did it take an egregious amount of time to get working--hence the comment of computer-literate. SW is only part of the problem as HW can be quite substantial too. I also did this with the cheap "chinesium" adapters too. Got them to work. Only paid like $10 for mine from Prince-AliExpress. Fixed my KOMBI :):thumbup:

crystalworks 05-13-2021 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bdc101 (Post 1203878)
I would guess it took me 8-10 hours of work to get it working, including finding help on two forums. I got it working, yes, but it was a huge hassle, and is the sort of thing that may differ greatly in effort and trouble based on what hardware you are using. If you have an old XP laptop it probably won't be "that bad." I read the same sort of suggestion online ("not that bad") and ended up wasting several evenings and weekend afternoons.

I agree. It sucks to setup using most SW packages available out there. Also reasonably proficient with a Windows machine. Took me 4-6 hours if memory serves to get INPA and the associated software suite setup. And then it sucks to use after that having to drag out the laptop if you are just doing something quick and simple. It's a great tool, but like most things in life... one solution to a problem is rarely going to be the best solution in all circumstances. I still have to setup ISTA+... which I'm sure will take me a weekend. :rolleyes:

I use all 3 of my diagnostic tools on the E53. Laptop, Foxwell, and Carly. Carly is the most convenient and does some coding, Foxwell is fairly comprehensive when it comes to diagnostics/testing but no coding, and the laptop is the most comprehensive while being the most annoying to use.

Getting upset someone else uses/recommends different solutions is bonkers.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:27 AM.

vBulletin, Copyright 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0
© 2017 Xoutpost.com. All rights reserved.