Take a look at the link and you can see the difference.

Rob_

I did and I still feel dumb, and I aint shame to admit it. Is it just looks or is there some functional difference??

Take a closer look at the 1st and 4th pics.

Rob_

Check out the link. The non-smokers is rubber lined so change won't rattle around, and it doesn't have the butt snuffer.

Yep I did and i guess it's because i don't smoke so I didn't see the round thing on the left hand side of the ash tray. I guess that's where you put out a cigerette. So you get more room and a holder that makes less noise.. Sorry I thought there was more to it. :doh: :banghead:

Not just less noise, no noise :p

I like that the non-smoker tray has the rubber bottom, but I need the snuffer hole on the left side of the standard ashtray because it fit my remote eye for my DVD player perfectly. ;)

http://www.xoutpost.com/images/articles/30/DSC01177.JPG

I use the non-smoker ashtray to put my sunglasses as I lost the over head place on my new X5 due to pano roof.

SG, where is the DIY for the center bin fish-tank mod?

Yeah that sun glass thing thru me off when I first got the X. I'm like pulling the spot where the sun glasses should go and dumb i go again.

HaHa, I lost that one when I got my new computer. It may still be at RF. I'll check later ;)